Talk Talk Talk Talk Talk Myself to Death: <i>The Glasgow School</i>

Tuesday, August 09, 2005

The Glasgow School

Today is a momentous day. Finally, almost thirty years after they originally formed as the Nu-Sonics and more than twenty years after they broke up for good, Orange Juice finally scores a U.S. release. The band went through several permutations over more than a dozen singles and three-and-a-half albums. Through it all, Edwyn Collins was the stalwart, the one constant through the band's entire history; he was front man, primary writer, and lead singer.

In many ways, Orange Juice was the personification of early '80s indie. As the name of this CD suggests, they were from Glasgow, Scotland (I know, I shouldn't have to specify that, but when I lived in Nashville, Tennessee, I told someone I was listening to a new band from Glasgow, and they asked, "Glasgow, Kentucky?"), which at that time wasn't even on the fringes of the London industry, so they had to set up their own local scene. That became Postcard Records (The Sound of Young Scotland), and Orange Juice recorded the first Postcard single, "Falling and Laughing." As it was all just beginning, there wasn't much money for record pressing, so less than a thousand were made (consequently, on the rare occasions it shows up on eBay, the bidding rises into the three figures). It was enough to catch the ear of the London music press, though, so the group got the support necessary to push forward. The band released three more singles (with larger pressings) and recorded an album's worth of demos. However, as the personification of early '80s indie, Orange Juice had no choice but to turn their backs on Postcard and sign to a major. They signed to Polydor and recorded their first album, You Can't Hide Your Love Forever, one of the all-time great pop artifacts. Even at the time, Steve Sutherland wrote in Melody Maker that it was "possibly the greatest record ever made," and it has only improved with age. But the original lineup broke up shortly after that album, and Orange Juice was never the same. Through two more albums and one mini-album, the group continued to be very good, but they never recaptured the exuberance, enthusiasm, and joie de vivre of the early material.

That's why it's lucky that The Glasgow School compiles all the Postcard material--four singles and B-sides and the unreleased-at-the-time album Ostrich Churchyard. In a sticker on the front of the CD, Alex Kapranos of Franz Ferdinand says:

Whenever I listen to [this music], I feel overwhelmed with idealistic optimism. I'm still thrilled by the adventurousness of the songwriting. . . . I still feel yes, anything IS possible.

He's right. When I opened the package and put the CD on, my eyes started to well up at the first strains of "Falling and Laughing." I'm not ashamed of saying, I was close to tears. And understand--I've already got most of this stuff. Except for a couple of bonuses at the end, I wasn't listening to anything I couldn't have played over the weekend or even as I was driving to the CD store this afternoon. But that just speaks to the power of the material. No matter how familiar it might become, it remains magnificent.

Do yourself a favor and pick up this CD. Not only is the music amazing, but it comes in a very handsome package. Extensive liner notes are provided by original Orange Juice drummer Steven Daly, who left the group and went on to a successful career as a journalist, working for Vanity Fair, among other outlets. Once you put it on, you'll hear things that sound oddly familiar if you follow today's indie music. The aforementioned Franz could easily drop "Breakfast Time" into the middle of their set without changing gears. And I think Interpol already covers "Simply Thrilled Honey," they just call it something else. (Don't forget to add a comment about where you hear Orange Juice's influence.) But don't just take my word for it. Look at what The Guardian has to say, or Glasgow's Sunday Herald. Pitchfork gives it a 9.3. A news release at the helpful Domino USA site offers links to images of reviews from Magnet, Blender, MOJO, Uncut, and Rolling Stone. But it's not all glowing. Time Out London apparently called it mostly "unlistenable."

On a less fortunate note, Edwyn Collins, who you may otherwise know from his 1995 hit "A Girl Like You," suffered a cerebral hemorrhage on February 20 of this year. He's through the worst part and is improving at a reasonable pace (though not as quickly as he'd like). Grace Maxwell, Edwyn's wife, has been extremely good about sharing updates on his progress at Edywn's bulletin board. The most recent is from a couple of weeks ago, and at that point, Grace said that the hospital intended to release Edwyn to continue his recovery at home some time next week. I'm sure she'll post again when Edwyn gets home, if not before.

5 Comments:

At 12:30 PM, August 10, 2005, Blogger Stuart Shea said...

It's easy to trip out the superlatives if you're a fan of what Orange Juice stood for: heartfelt, spiky, soulful, classic-inspired but thoroughly unimitative post-punk pop rock. (That's a lot of qualifiers, but in a nutshell, many groups tried but failed to do it as well.)

While I understood Edwyn's soul-boy conversion in the mid 80s, I thought it was a bit too ironic, too polished, and too desperate. And while I'm glad to think of him finally getting hits in the 90s, he's never really recaptured what he had back in the Postcard/You Can't Hide Your Love Forever days. Then again at least he had it; few groups ever had it like OJ did.

 
At 6:22 PM, August 10, 2005, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Everything Edwyn did was ironic to some extent. I agree on the soul stuff. You can see the seeds of it at Postcard, but I would've been happier if he'd held on to the perfect pop side of the equation a little bit harder.

I'm not sure whether he could've recaptured whatever that original quality was. We'll never know how much of it was just Edwyn being in the right place at the right time with the right message. Maybe it was a function of the interplay among the original group line up. Edwyn has since said that he should have gone with James Kirk and Steven Daly in the post-You Can't Hide Your Love split, although cracks were developing between them, too, so it may not have been able to last anyway. But it would have been interesting to see if, among the three original Nu-Sonics, the soul of Orange Juice could've survived a little while longer.

 
At 6:32 PM, August 10, 2005, Blogger Stuart Shea said...

I actually liked what Malcolm Ross and Zeke Manyika brought to Orange Juice...unlike I guess everyone else in the world, I liked the "Two Hearts Together" 45 (it was sort of a song of Cecilia's and mine in the early days of our relationship) and a lot of what was on the Rip it Up album. My problems came later, I guess...they seemed to lose all the pop influence. To that extent, yes, Edwyn needed a reminder.

 
At 10:36 PM, August 10, 2005, Anonymous Anonymous said...

I never understood why Edwyn so disliked "Two Hearts Together." It doesn't do much for me, but it certainly seems of a piece with the Rip It Up album. I found that one to have its high points but to be mixed. I liked Texas Fever, and although there's a heavy soul influence on the third album, I thought it did have a couple of points of pop pleasure.

Edwyn's first solo single, though, "Don't Shilly Shally" on Alan McGee's Elevation label, was in my eyes a return to form after several years of seclusion. I had extremely high hopes, but when it didn't sell and its follow-up did even worse, he seemed to go underground again.

 
At 6:15 PM, December 13, 2006, Anonymous Anonymous said...

ORANGE JUICE III (or "the third album" as it was known, even tho it was their fourth) stands the test of time more than anything else. love that damn "Salmon Fishing in New York" more every time I hear it. it's like "What Do I Get?" - never gets boring, just more exciting. Im lost without Orange Juice. He just married his 2 decades long girlfriend Grace, this past weekend. Cool.

 

Post a Comment

<< Home