Maybe One New Wrinkle
Although the administration's attitude toward the American public so far seems to have been "Ask not what you can do for your country," Bush did change his tune a little bit tonight. He closed with this paragraph:
And to those watching tonight who are considering a military career, there is no higher calling than service in our Armed Forces. We live in freedom because every generation has produced patriots willing to serve a cause greater than themselves. Those who serve today are taking their rightful place among the greatest generations that have worn our nation's uniform. When the history of this period is written, the liberation of Afghanistan and the liberation of Iraq will be remembered as great turning points in the story of freedom.
Lofty sentiments, indeed. Max Blumenthal, reporting from the College Republican National Convention in The Nation's Website this week, lets us know how such an appeal might be received:
In interviews, more than a dozen conventiongoers explained why it is important that they stay on campus while other, less fortunate people their age wage a bloody war in Iraq. They strongly support the war, they told me, but they also want to enjoy college life and pursue interesting careers. Being a College Republican allows them to do both. It is warfare by other, much safer means.. . .
I chatted for a while with Collin Kelley, a senior at Washington State. . . . Kelley told me he's "sick and tired of people saying our troops are dying in vain" and added, "This isn't an invasion of Iraq, it's a liberation--as David Horowitz said." When I asked him why he was staying on campus rather than fighting the good fight, he rubbed his shoulder and described a nagging football injury from high school. Plus, his parents didn't want him to go. "They're old hippies," Kelley said.
Munching on a chicken quesadilla at a table nearby was Edward Hauser, a senior at St. Edwards University in Austin, Texas--a liberal school in a liberal town in the ultimate red state of Texas. "Austin is ninety square miles insulated from reality," Hauser said. When I broached the issue of Iraq, he replied, "I support our country. I support our troops." So why isn't he there?
"I know that I'm going to be better staying here and working to convince people why we're there [in Iraq]," Hauser explained, pausing in thought. "I'm a fighter, but with words.". . .
By the time I encountered Cory Bray, a towering senior from the University of Pennsylvania's Wharton School of Business, the beer was flowing freely. "The people opposed to the war aren't putting their asses on the line," Bray boomed from beside the bar. Then why isn't he putting his ass on the line? "I'm not putting my ass on the line because I had the opportunity to go to the number-one business school in the country," he declared, his voice rising in defensive anger, "and I wasn't going to pass that up."
And besides, being a College Republican is so much more fun than counterinsurgency warfare. Bray recounted the pride he and his buddies had felt walking through the center of campus last fall waving a giant American flag, wearing cowboy boots and hats with the letters B-U-S-H painted on their bare chests. "We're the big guys," he said. "We're the ones who stand up for what we believe in. The College Democrats just sit around talking about how much they hate Bush. We actually do shit."
3 Comments:
Nice post.
As appalling as those College Republicans are, they are only one facet of a larger, non-partisan issue. The fact is, there are plenty of people who give lip service to all sorts of different viewpoints, with no interest in backing them up with any direct involvement. Yes, you have your war supporters and your Bush supporters who are all too willing to let others shed blood for the sake of their comfort. At the same time, you also have legions of people who might tell you how much they disapprove of Bush, and what a doofus they think he is, but who are just as willing as any College Republican to let others do the fighting. It reminds me of an article that the late, great Abbie Hoffman wrote for Parade(!) some years back. He said that "democracy is not something you possess; it's something you do. It is an activity. And if you don't do it, you don't have it." And let me be clear on this -- I do not hold myself up as an example for how to "do democracy," as Hoffman put it. I have considerable room for improvement in that realm. Perhaps I'm guilty of the same thing as that fellow you quoted who said, "I'm a fighter, but with words." But words are the standard unit of currency on a blog, so this is my contribution.
I agree, Chuck, that it's much easier to make a claim than to follow through and do something about it, and that it's something we all fall into from time to time. But in this case, when the pack of lies this war is based on becomes more and more obvious, to continue supporting the war anyway demands a higher level of responsibility than the classic Cheney "I've got other priorities" dodge.
Post a Comment
<< Home